3 Reasons Consumer Electronics Sucks on Amazon.co.uk

No primary category set

Stuart from Freedom Mobiles is well versed in the selling of consumer electronics as he also runs Tablet Monster and iPad-Recycle. However he has some specific complaints about Amazon which make selling consumer electronics tricky:

Amazon is a well-oiled machine for selling bar-coded items such as books and DVDs. Naturally this has transferred buyers from these smaller ticket items to the same trusted checkout flow of higher end consumer electronics; tablets and mobile phones for example.

There are however some serious failings in the Amazon approach which have been identified and communicated by ourselves at Freedom-Mobiles.com, but completely dismissed by the Amazon Catalogue team. Have a look for yourself on Amazon and see if you agree with the points raised below.

1) Catalogue Inconsistencies

The catalogue itself is a mess, there is no consistency or naming convention whatsoever. Have a quick search for “iPad” and you will see what we mean here. Apple have only created specific model lines so there really is no excuse for shoddily worded third party entries here. Not to mention the “relevance metric” Amazon applies which is mysterious at best.

2) Network locked mobile phones

Network Locked Mobile iPhonesThere is no system in place for selling network locked mobiles. Amazon don’t have a policy on this. The well versed company response on this is that you must have the identical product for sale as the catalogue item – the problem is a network locked phone is identical to an unlocked one, in as much as the UPC or MPN is the same.

Having a separate catalogue entry per network would be one possibility. However this would multiply an already chaotic catalogue. In all likelihood the buyer will find the generic SIM Free listing and choose from the private low volume sellers for whom making a catalogue entry “error” has no impact. A good argument would be to put the network in the condition note i.e. the seller generated description for the item, or would it…

3) Condition Notes

…Buyers don’t read the seller generated condition note. On eBay this is a classic very low percentage problem, but on Amazon it is rife. Statistically we have found that as many as 10% of buyers don’t SEE the detailed condition description. This is a system error, but sadly not one which Amazon feels is important. The detailed description is hidden away on the right hand side and even requires a click to read most of the text. For used items, detailed condition is vital.

Consumer Electronics on Play.com

Let’s hope Play.com can learn from these failings. Current performance shows they are doing very well at making descriptions prominent but caught napping when it comes to catalogue naming convention and search relevance. Have a quick search on play.com for “ipad 2 64gb” and try to believe your eyes.

Rant over!

2 Responses

  1. On the locked/unlocked side of things, could they create variations so the buyer selects which one they require? If they only showed the parent page in search then it could be a solution?

    I’m looking at Play.com for a client and Play don’t currently have a specific relevant catalogue for the clients products. Bizarrely, Play.com told me to first see if any other sellers of similar lines had listed, and if so categorise them the same, or failing that, put them wherever I thought – lets hope we see a little more organisation than that in the future!


MediaMarkt marketplace growth in 2023

MediaMarkt marketplace growth in 2023

Excess Consumer Electronics over stock

Excess Consumer Electronics over stock

Man shopping scanning qr code advertising with smartphone on clo

Whistl launches GDPR compliant Partially Addressed Mail solution for advertisers


OnBuy announce new focus on Refurbished Electronics


eBay product-based commerce experience not working well for existing buyers

ChannelX Guide...

Featured in this article from the ChannelX Guide – companies that can help you grow and manage your business.


Take a look through a selection of the latest articles on ChannelX

Register for Newsletter

Receive 5 newsletters per week

Gain access to all research

Be notified of upcoming events and webinars