eBay product-based commerce experience not working well for existing buyers

No primary category set

In the latest eBay earnings call, eBay President and CEO Devin Wenig revealed that the new eBay product-based commerce experience isn’t working well for existing eBay users.

It’s not all bad news – compressing hundreds of listings into a single search result is apparently being well received by newcomers to eBay, but it’s not so well received by buyers who have been shopping on eBay for decades. This has limited eBay’s ability to scale the new experience and Devin went so far as to say “we don’t want to screw up the existing ecosystem”.

“Certain of our services have been well-received across the board and others have then take more time, and an example of something that takes more time, that is really going well with new customers but is taking more time, is a full product-based commerce experience where we fully compress the product side.
What we see is that, as you would expect, new customers who don’t – haven’t shopped with eBay before come to it and they respond very well to that. Existing customers, some of them shop on eBay. They’ve been shopping on eBay for 20 years, so it’s a new experience and there’s always some friction when you change an experience. I think some of it is time and habituation. Some of it is education, and as we said, our approach is going to change a little bit, which does slow things down a bit. And that is we’ll go fast with new customers and we’ll go slower with the existing base and over time, the mix will change.
So we’re still very confident in what we’re doing and we do believe that the existing base will evolve and it’ll come along but we are very conscious that we don’t want to screw up the existing ecosystem. We have a good, stable base of customers, a very successful business, and we don’t want to disrupt that. So we’ll be more aggressive with the new and we’ll go a bit slower with the existing buyers and eventually, we’ll get them both there.”

– Devin Wenig, President and CEO, eBay

This goes some way to explain why eBay deferred the second phase roll out of the product-based commerce experience until some point in 2019, well after the Black Friday and Christmas shopping period are out of the way. The reason sellers are grateful has nothing to do with the buyer experience, but the fact they don’t believe eBay is ready with the catalogue, that the process for editing and adding products to the catalogue is slick enough and that they have sufficient time as Q4 hots up to amend their existing listings and match new listing to the catalogue.

eBay are caught between a rock and a hard place. In order to expand and attract new buyers to the marketplace the PBSE experience appears to be a more compelling buying experience. Existing eBay buyers that have used the marketplace for anything up to two decades or more can’t be ignored or eBay will lose their current revenues and sellers will lose sales.

Slowing the transition to a product-based commerce experience will please sellers as it gives more time to adjust listings and keeps sales flowing from buyers who currently dislike the new experience. We’ll wait now to see how slow the roll out takes place – probably to be announced in the first eBay seller release of 2019, and if the new time scales ease sellers concerns and keep existing eBay buyers buying.

7 Responses

  1. This kinda sums up my best friend. He has had an eBay account since 1999 nearly 10 years before I even looked at it , he works on the rigs and gets paid a fortune for sitting about most the time twiddling his thumbs gets bored and goes searching for bargains. Now his type of bargains what I mean he thinks nothing of spending £600 on a watch not Tat from China bargains.
    He likes his watches, cars, guitars, and cameras and he has money to spunk.
    He has probably spent all small fortune over the years, and “loves hunting for a bargain”….that is what he gets a kick out off.

    He has not bought a bean on eBay in two years now. He says eBay is just full of junk or is overpriced now and does not feel he can go and get a deal, so he has given up with it.
    He tends to do all his wheeling and dealing on forums like Piston heads.

  2. wow. who’d have thought the amazon-like layout suits those that historically shop on amazon rather than ebay.
    sure the layout is preferable to them, but is that enough to tempt a loyal amazon customer to convert to ebay? i doubt it.
    is it enough to tempt the loyal ebay users to try amazon instead? probably.

  3. I don’t like it, browsing through listings rather than being told “this is the one you will pick” is far less fun.

  4. Wenig: “we are very conscious that we don’t want to screw up the existing ecosystem”

    Far far too effing late.

    You HAVE screwed Ebay up.

    We listened to your techno-babble at the start and had doubts, buy hey, it’s just possible that someone who talks gibberish might be some sort of genius underneath it all.

    Wenig, you ain’t no genius.

    Ebay is flatlining and your focus now is to screw the remaining sellers for whatever you can get .

    Wenig, you should resign. You have failed. You have let down millions of sellers who rely on Ebay for a living. You have let down buyers with a poor shopping experience, whilst Amazon’s grows like knotweed.

    Bezos wouldn’t give you a job cleaning his car.

    As Cromwell said to Charles I, “In the name of God go!”

  5. Ebay was fun to sell on at one time now they are the same as Amazon. Gey your money and lets have a glitch every day.
    So sad as I loved buying from Ebay, I buy less now.


eBay UK returns as Love Island sponsor to promote pre-loved fashion

eBay UK returns as Love Island sponsor to promote pre-loved fashion

eBay Roadshow Belfast - 13th June

eBay Roadshow Belfast – 13th June

eBay's new resell button transforms recommerce experience

eBay’s new resell button transforms recommerce experience

eBay & Small Business Britain Webinar: From Side Hustle to Main Hustle

eBay & Small Business Britain Webinar: From Side Hustle to Main Hustle

eBay Official Partner of McLaren Formula 1 Team

eBay Official Partner of McLaren Formula 1 Team

ChannelX Guide...

Featured in this article from the ChannelX Guide – companies that can help you grow and manage your business.

Register for Newsletter

Receive 5 newsletters per week

Gain access to all research

Be notified of upcoming events and webinars