Basecamp fire back at Google over Paid Ads ‘Ransom’

No primary category set

The issue of Google Ads has been highlighted by Basecamp, a workflow solution, who exasperated by seeing competitor’s paid adverts appear ahead of them in search results decided to buy an ad themselves to make their point. Their ad called out that they have (as they rightly should) the number #1 position in search for their brand name but up to four competitors are routinely ahead of them in search results as they pay to be there.

Google’s rules say that you can’t include trademarked brand names in your paid ads, but they are perfectly willing to allow you to bid on competitor’s trademarks. These keywords are likely what people search for on Google and if you search for a trademark then any ads with that trademark as a keyword can appear ahead of the real brand in search.

A common complaint is that ads today look very much like organic search results. Consumers may or may not see a small image or some greyed out text identifying a search result as an ad but this is easy to miss. It opens the question of trust as if someone can buy themselves to the top of search results is the site trustworthy?

Closer to home, we did an Google search for Linnworks and instantly saw two paid adverts above their organic search result:

Linnworks Google Paid Ads

Similarly another company operating in the marketplace world, Payoneer, shows a similar set of ads bidding on their brand name:

Payoneer Google Paid Ads

This is nothing new, it’s similar to marketplaces such as eBay with their Promoted Listings and Amazon with Sponsored Ads and Sponsored Brands. If someone is willing to pay then the can trump your position in search results.

There are some companies, PriceSearcher for instance, where bidding on competitor’s trademarks is simply not allowed. However if you’re looking for exposure on Google, eBay, Amazon or many other venues the only way to ensure that your product is at the top of search results is to do what Basecamp have done, open your wallet, and buy you way back to the top.

2 Responses

  1. I’m surprised the Ad even got approved.

    According to Google they review your Ad each time you either create one, or make a change to an existing one, and this review takes 1 business day (on average) and is apparently reviewed manually by a human.

    To me this confirms that’s a load of rubbish. As no human reviewer in their right mind would have allowed such an Ad to be approved.

  2. Jay with the amount of Ads I upload for one of my clients there is no way they are manually reviewed.
    as for brand bidding yes google does allow it, but you can register your trademark which will make it much harder to happen, but don’t forget bing they are very tough on brand bidding you will find it very hard to bid on a competitors term unless you have a very good case


SkateHut ready as skateboarding returns to Paris 2024 Olympics

SkateHut ready as skateboarding returns to Paris 2024 Olympics

New eBay Advertising Dashboard & Data-Driven Recommendations

New eBay Advertising Dashboard & Data-Driven Recommendations

ChannelX Marketplace Guide 2024

ChannelX Marketplace Guide 2024

Google Cloud announces gen AI updates with Stagwell

Google Cloud announces gen AI updates with Stagwell

New YouTube Shopping Collections

New YouTube Shopping Collections

ChannelX Guide...

Featured in this article from the ChannelX Guide – companies that can help you grow and manage your business.


Take a look through a selection of the latest articles on ChannelX

Register for Newsletter

Receive 5 newsletters per week

Gain access to all research

Be notified of upcoming events and webinars